Here are links to documents referenced in Resolution 21-31, entitled “URGING THE ADMINISTRATION TO RENEW AND EXTEND WATER AND SEWER CREDITS TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS FOR HOMESTEAD AND AGRICULTURAL LOTS IN LAHAINA, MAUI, HAWAII,” adopted on March 5, 2021:
“Prince Jonah Kūhiō Kalanaiana‘ole, Hawaiian Ali‘i & Congressional Delegate,” by Professor Davianna Pōmaika‘i McGregor: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.422.2009&rep=rep1&type=pdf
Hawaii News Now, “Hawaii Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Hawaiian Homelands Beneficiaries, by Chelsea Davis”: https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/07/01/hawaii-supreme-court-rules-favor-hawaiian-homelands-beneficiaries/
Wastewater Allocation Agreement, dated April 23, 2008, between County of Maui, Department of Environmental Management, and State of Hawaii, Department of Hawaiian Homelands: https://mauicounty.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=9211812&GUID=0E70DEA3-13FA-4EF5-8D3A-E81587C5C8CC
Correspondence dated November 23, 2020, Maui County Councilmember Tamara Paltin to Department of Hawaiian Home Lands Chair William J. Aila: https://mauicounty.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=9211812&GUID=0E70DEA3-13FA-4EF5-8D3A-E81587C5C8CC
Civil Beat, “It’s Time To Acknowledge Native Hawaiians’ Special Right To Housing, by Williamson Chang and Abbey Seitz”: https://www.civilbeat.org/2021/01/its-time-to-acknowledge-native-hawaiians-special-right-to-housing/
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: September 18, 2019
Press Release by:
Councilmember Tamara Paltin
Maui County Council
Councilmember Tamara Paltin weighs in on injection well conflict question
WAILUKU, Hawaii – Councilmember Tamara Paltin, who holds the West Maui residency area seat on the Maui County Council, issued the following statement today:
On Monday, September 16, 2019, I was informed of the following by a local media outlet: “On Wednesday, the ethics board will take up a complaint filed by a member of the public alleging that you should not vote on the injection well settlement matter because you were on the board of West Maui Preservation Association (“WMPA”) – one of the plaintiffs of the lawsuit -when it was filed. Please let us know if you would like to include a response to this complaint for our story.”
The Board of Ethics has since cancelled its “Special Meeting” for Wednesday, September 18, 2019. However, the agenda posted for that date contains an item that refers to Complaint No. 19-06 against “a County official” with no other identifying information.
Additionally, the agenda was not posted with due notice, six days prior to the meeting, as mandated by the Sunshine Law. I requested to view the complaint and was told that it was confidential and could not be accessed until first released in open session during a Board of Ethics meeting.
Following is my reply to the media request for comment: “Mahalo for this email. This is the first that I have heard of a complaint filed against me and the first that I have heard of this special meeting. I disclosed my previous affiliation with WMPA on my campaign website and on my candidate financial disclosure statement. I resigned from this nonprofit organization prior to taking office, and I have no financial interest directly or indirectly nor any fiduciary responsibility in the organization, having served as a volunteer.”
I came onto the WMPA board after the County had lost at the Ninth Circuit and before the Supreme Court agreed to hear the County’s appeal—when nothing was going on.
I resigned from WMPA before taking office. My tenure on WMPA involved the six shoreline access lawsuits that were filed in conjunction with Na Papa‘i Wawae ‘Ulaʻula, and those did not directly implicate the County.
Pursuing this complaint is both ludicrous and a frivolous waste of taxpayer money, especially given the history of former nonprofit directors and executives voting on items involving their former or current nonprofit affiliations after they joined the council.
For example, former Councilmember Gladys Baisa regularly voted on Maui Economic Opportunity’s funding issues despite her former paid capacity as the organization’s executive director. Councilmember Yuki Lei Sugimura was previously involved in Wailuku First Fridays and now votes for its funding through the budget process.
In the most recent Board of Ethics meeting, Councilmember Tasha Kama was cleared to vote on the Bank of America case, initiated in part by the nonprofit Na Poe Kokua, of which she founded and is currently a director. In this case, Councilmember Kama could potentially benefit by receiving a loan.
In addition, there were no objections to my predecessor, former Councilmember Elle Cochran, voting to retain special counsel in the injection well case even though she had been a plaintiff.
I was not on the WMPA board when the injection well case was filed in 2012 or when the County lost before the district court or the appeals court. This purported complaint against me is simply a smear campaign by a party that supports inadequate oversight of our ocean waters.
The Board of Ethics has apparently not held a ‘”special meeting” following a regular meeting in any calendar month in more than 15 years. Corporation Counsel, which staffs the Board of Ethics, should voluntarily recognize that they have a conflict regarding their professional responsibility in this matter and advise the board to seek approval to hire an outside attorney, if the complaint moves forward.
I would also suggest an investigation into the leaking of this confidential complaint.
For more information, contact the office of Councilmember Paltin at (808) 270-5504 or Tamara.Paltin@mauicounty.us.
Telephone: (808) 270-5504 (Councilmember Paltin)
- Councilmember Paltin’s letter to UH President Lassner dated July 26, 2019 — “PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF THE THIRTY-METER TELESCOPE ON THE SUMMIT OF MAUNA KEA (COMMUNICATION II)” — and his reply to her July 12th letter are here:
- Councilmember Paltin’s press release dated July 14, 2019: COUNCILMEMBER PALTIN ISSUES URGENT APPEAL TO UH PRESIDENT TO STAND DOWN ON TMT DUE TO INVALIDITY OF UH’S GENERAL LEASE AND SERIOUS VIOLATIONS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW [gview file=”http://mauicounty.us/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/TMT-Ltr-Press-Release.pdf”]
- Councilmember Paltin’s letter to University of Hawai`i System President David Lassner dated July 12, 2019: PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF THIRTY-METER TELESCOPE ON THE SUMMIT OF MAUNA KEA [gview file=”http://mauicounty.us/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Lassner-2019-07-12.pdf”]
- Angela Lucero, Executive Assistant
- Christi Keliikoa, Executive Assistant
- Krystal Cabiles, Executive Assistant
District Office Staff
Old Lahaina Center
845 Wainee Street
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Kalana O Maui Building
200 South High St.
Wailuku, Hawaii 96793
Ph : (808) 270-5504
Fax: (808) 270-5505