• News
  • Agendas
  • Councilmembers
    • Alice L. Lee
    • Keani Rawlins-Fernandez
    • Gabe Johnson
    • Tasha Kama
    • Kelly Takaya King
    • Mike Molina
    • Tamara Paltin
    • Shane Sinenci
    • Yuki Lei Sugimura
  • Committees
    • Affordable Housing Committee
    • Agriculture and Public Trust Committee
    • Budget, Finance, and Economic Development Committee
    • Climate Action, Resilience, and Environment Committee
    • Government Relations, Ethics, and Transparency Committee
    • Human Concerns and Parks Committee
    • Infrastructure and Transportation Committee
    • Planning and Sustainable Land Use Committee
  • Testify
    • eComment: The best option for submitting written testimony to Council committees.
    • Agenda Email Alerts
  • Council Meetings
  • Resources
    • 2022 Council Calendar
    • Maui County Kākou: Civic Engagement Video Series
    • PRESS RELEASES
    • General announcements
    • Planning Commission Referrals
    • COVID-19 COMMUNITY RESOURCES
    • Public Safety
    • Request for Proposals
    • Solicitations
    • Audits
    • Training and Professional Development Reports
  • Elections
  • Contact
  • FAQ

MauiCounty.us

  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • InstagramInstagram
  • News
  • Agendas
  • Councilmembers
    • Alice L. Lee
    • Keani Rawlins-Fernandez
    • Gabe Johnson
    • Tasha Kama
    • Kelly Takaya King
    • Mike Molina
    • Tamara Paltin
    • Shane Sinenci
    • Yuki Lei Sugimura
  • Committees
    • Affordable Housing Committee
    • Agriculture and Public Trust Committee
    • Budget, Finance, and Economic Development Committee
    • Climate Action, Resilience, and Environment Committee
    • Government Relations, Ethics, and Transparency Committee
    • Human Concerns and Parks Committee
    • Infrastructure and Transportation Committee
    • Planning and Sustainable Land Use Committee
  • Testify
    • eComment: The best option for submitting written testimony to Council committees.
    • Agenda Email Alerts
  • Council Meetings
  • Resources
    • 2022 Council Calendar
    • Maui County Kākou: Civic Engagement Video Series
    • PRESS RELEASES
    • General announcements
    • Planning Commission Referrals
    • COVID-19 COMMUNITY RESOURCES
    • Public Safety
    • Request for Proposals
    • Solicitations
    • Audits
    • Training and Professional Development Reports
  • Elections
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Laws & Resolutions
  • Maui County Charter
  • Maui County Code
  • Council’s 3 Minutes
  • Countywide Policy Plan
  • Office of Council Services
  • MauiCounty.gov
  • Public Record Requests
    • Latest Stories

      What is new?

    • Digital zoning map proposes to rezone properties consistent with their use and designation

      May 20, 2022

    • Budget balances fiscal resources with community needs

      May 9, 2022

Budget & Finance · Chair's 3 Minutes · Economic Development · Hawaii State Association of Counties · Infrastructure · Public Safety · State Legislature · Transportation

State wants to keep TAT at expense of counties

  • by Alison Stewart
  • February 21, 2017

Chair’s 3 Minutes
Published in The Maui News, Feb. 19, 2017
By Mike White

On Tuesday, the state House Committee on Tourism advanced House Bill 1586, which phases out the counties’ share of the transient accommodations tax, also known as the TAT or hotel tax. County officials were present and expressed strong opposition to the measure, yet the state still wants to consider keeping all of the TAT. This measure would help the state balance its budget, of course, but at an enormous cost to county taxpayers.

In short, the state’s plan is unfair and unacceptable.

Every hotel or lodging transaction includes a 9.25 percent hotel tax surcharge collected by the state to compensate for a visitor’s use of state and county services. Counties are particularly impacted because they provide important services upon which visitors most depend. These include environmental protection; police, fire and ocean safety; development and upkeep of most roads; and parks maintenance.

Without a fair share of TAT, the burden of providing county services to visitors would increasingly be transferred to our local residents, even though visitors have already been taxed. This is already happening. From 2007 to 2015, counties have incurred over $170 million in cost increases in services for fire, police and parks, but have only seen an additional $2.2 million from TAT revenues. This is while the state took an increased portion of $196.6 million.

The Hawaii Tourism Authority projects an annual increase in the visitor population with more TAT monies raised each year. Additional visitors would mean an increased demand for county services, resulting in higher operational costs.

Front Street Lahaina

A more rational approach would be to increase the distribution of TAT funds using a percentage-based formula. But instead, the Legislature last year continued the cap on the counties’ share at $103 million. And now it wants to eliminate the counties’ share altogether.

The total TAT collected in 2010 was $244 million. In 2015, it grew to $435 million. Even if another million visitors arrive in Hawaii, the counties will still receive a fixed amount for reimbursements — unless the Legislature takes action to give the counties a more equitable share.

Maui County generates approximately $130 million in TAT revenue, but under the state’s current cap we receive only $23.5 million in return. If this amount is further reduced, the county will face major budgetary shortfalls. The county will likely have to raise real property tax or reduce services. This could range from reducing lifeguards at public beaches, cutbacks to youth and senior programs, or other programs our residents depend upon. Neither are attractive options, but there is a better way.

At the same hearing on Tuesday, the committee passed House Bill 317, which is included in the Hawaii State Association of Counties package. The bill would remove the arbitrarily placed cap and implement a 55-45 percent split of the remaining TAT revenue, after specific appropriations, between the state and counties.

That measure is supported by a comprehensive study on the history and purpose of the TAT by a working group created by the Legislature in 2015. The report found that counties are responsible for 54 percent of net expenditures directly supporting tourism, while the state provides 46 percent.

The working group has made its recommendation, yet some legislators chose to ignore the report they asked for.

This measure also follows past practices. The counties previously received 45 percent of TAT revenues until the state reallocated the fund to help balance its budget during the economic downturn in 2009.

I urge the community to be educated and more vigilant this session — our hard-earned dollars are on the line. The counties indeed deserve more.

We will continue to closely monitor bills in the state Legislature and hope you can help urge our state legislators to return an equitable share of the TAT to the counties. It is not fair for you to be paying for visitors’ expenses after they have already paid their fair share.

Go to mauicounty.us/2017stateleg for copies of testimony submitted.

* Mike White is chair of the Maui County Council. He holds the council seat for the Paia-Haiku-Makawao residency area. “Chair’s 3 Minutes” is a weekly column to explain the latest news on county legislative matters. Go to mauicounty.us for more information.

  • Tweet

Tags: hotel taxHSACtransient accommodations tax

  • Previous story Cochran applauds movement towards pesticide-free parks operations
  • Next story Community support is critical in moving state bills

    Related Posts

  • roads County impacted as Legislature gets set to adjourn May 1, 2017
  • Become a precinct official Volunteer election workers sought; state-county relationships discussed June 23, 2014
  • Domestic violence Domestic Violence Awareness Month is recognized October 12, 2015
  • Emilia Istrate Counties move Hawaii forward at HSAC Conference July 9, 2015
  • Webcast meetings

  • Video

  • Announcements

    • Watch the Civic Engagement Video Series: Maui County Kākou.

    • Sign up to receive meeting agendas by email.

    • Maui County Youth Council Application

     

  • Quick links

    • 2022 Council Calendar
    • 2023 Fiscal Year Budget Session
    • 2022 State Legislative Session
    • Transient Accommodations Tax
    • Civic Engagement Video Series
    • How To Testify
    • List of Councilmembers
    • 2021 Council Inauguration
    • 2021 State Legislative Session
    • Affordable Housing Reports
    • Training and Development Reports
    • Procurement Awards and Exemptions
    • West Maui Community Plan
    • Molokai Community Plan Update
    • Lanai Community Plan Update
    • Directory of State, County and Federal Officials
    • Maui County Youth Council Application

    Questions? Email media@mauicounty.us

  • Get the latest news @mauicounty on Twitter.

    Tweets by @mauicounty
  • Official Facebook page

    • Track documents online

      Less Paper Initiative: Files, videos of Maui County Council me...

      Posted by Maui County Council on Sunday, March 20, 2016
    • Recent Posts

      • Digital zoning map proposes to rezone properties consistent with their use and designation
      • Budget balances fiscal resources with community needs
      • WE’RE HIRING: Procurement Specialist
      • Receiving community testimony in new hybrid model
      • Invitation for Bids – Interior Renovations
    • Help

      If you are having a technical problem viewing our content, please email us at county.council@mauicounty.us and let us know how we can improve the site. Mahalo!

    • Categories

    • FacebookFacebook
    • TwitterTwitter
    • InstagramInstagram

    © Maui County Council • All rights reserved